Who Gets toBuild It?
Technology, jewelry and the assumptions that shape how we judge an idea.
“Why are you making jewelry?”
It was 2020, and our cohort of Italian startups was presenting to mentors and investors in a New York accelerator program conducted remotely during the pandemic. Other founders were pitching software platforms and enterprise services. I was explaining how we could integrate electronic components into precious metals—and why we were making jewelry to demonstrate it.
But the conversation stopped following the technology. The questions kept returning to why a technology company was manufacturing physical pieces at all.
A detour, or the strategy?
What was treated as a detour was our commercial strategy. We had designed the business around two routes: bringing our own finished jewelry to market and offering the technology to other manufacturers for integration into their products. Making the pieces allowed us to put the technology into use, test demand, learn from customers and demonstrate what another brand could incorporate into its own production.
Who was I to enter this space?
During a session with a mentor from a major luxury group, the conversation became more pointed. His background was in menswear design. After hearing the proposal, he questioned, in essence, who I was to enter this space. Wasn’t this the kind of project an established luxury house should undertake?
His experience inside a major group was relevant. What I questioned was the assumption that an idea like this needed to originate there.
I told him that a smaller company could organise itself around a problem that might compete with many other priorities inside a large business. But agility alone would not pay for development or bring a product to market. We needed engineers, jewelry-making expertise, reliable production, capital and customers. Those were the questions I wanted to examine: what we could do, what we still lacked and how we would close the gaps.
Where the idea began
My reasons for pursuing the idea began long before that conversation.
For much of my career, I had worked in technology and international business, helping technology companies expand into international markets. My work spanned IT services, systems integration and industrial environments, including automotive and oil and gas, where devices, control systems and software had to function together under demanding conditions.
A solution had to fit an operation already in motion. Different specialists were responsible for different parts, and decisions could have consequences well beyond the component being introduced. It was not enough to demonstrate that something worked. We needed to understand where it belonged, who would use it and what would happen when conditions changed.
Through that work, I had encountered the difficulty of integrating electronic components into metal.
An object outlives its information
Alongside my professional life, I had spent more than twenty-five years following jewelry, precious materials, art and design. I attended fairs, visited galleries and studied how pieces were made, appraised and resold. Increasingly, I became interested in what happened after a jewel left the shop.
A piece might remain with its owner for decades. It could be repaired, altered, given away, inherited or resold. Yet the information describing it might be held elsewhere: on a certificate, in a receipt, in a brand’s records or in someone’s memory. The object continued its life while the information became harder to recover.
I began asking whether an electronic component integrated into the precious metal could keep an individual piece connected to a digital record.
We brought together engineering, jewelry making and software expertise to develop the integration, build working prototypes and bring finished pieces to market. Customers bought them. We also explored offering the technology to other manufacturers for use in their own products.
The component gives the piece an identifier linked to a record. That record can hold information about the object and its materials, accessible to the relevant brand, distributor or owner. It does not, by itself, make every entry accurate. Claims about origin still depend on the documentation, checks and people behind them.
That distinction mattered. We were developing a way to connect an object to information, not a substitute for establishing whether the information could be trusted.
Continuity is not competence
To someone looking only at my career history, the move into jewelry might have appeared to be a departure. For me, it was also a continuation: another way of connecting physical things, information and the people who needed to use it.
But continuity did not mean competence in every part of the new business. Years in enterprise technology had not taught me how gold behaves during casting or how an individual customer decides to buy a jewel. I had to learn, and I had to work with specialists who knew what I did not. My background gave me a starting point. It did not remove the need for theirs.
Two kinds of attention
As I presented the business, I also began noticing a recurring contrast.
Most of the investors I met were men. Mention watches and the conversation became fluent: engineering, provenance, resale value. Many wore the object we were discussing. Mention jewelry and that analytical attention gave way to the language of gifts and decoration.
I found myself repeatedly redirecting the discussion toward the materials, craftsmanship and information an owner would need when a piece was repaired, inherited or resold.
Yet the global jewelry market is roughly three times the size of the watch market. This was not a smaller opportunity. It was a market they knew less intimately.
A watch on a man’s wrist invited questions about mechanics and value. A jewel worn by a woman was treated as an aesthetic choice. The materials, craftsmanship and need for reliable information had not disappeared. Their attention had shifted.
How much of what we call
business judgment is simply recognition of our own lives?
A different conversation
At a family office gathering in Rome, I experienced a different kind of conversation. I sat down with an investor from California whose background was in industrial manufacturing. As I explained the relationship between my industrial experience, the integration of electronics into precious metal and the business we had developed, we moved into the practical questions: making the pieces, reaching customers and offering the technology to other manufacturers.
I did not have to spend the conversation defending why these worlds belonged together. We could discuss what connecting them would require.
His fund did not invest in Europe. I left without an investment, but the exchange stayed with me. I had been able to explain the business and hear questions about the work itself. I did not leave knowing the idea would succeed. I left thinking more clearly about what it would take.
Scrutiny is not dismissal
The two encounters did not establish who was right about the business. They made me more attentive to how people reach a judgment—and whether their questions allow them to discover something their first impression missed.
Those experiences changed how I participate in conversations about my work. Years of working across industries have made me more assertive about the distinction between scrutiny and dismissal. I welcome difficult questions about what I know, what I have built and where my reasoning falls short. I no longer accept familiarity with one field as authority to dismiss the connection with another.
I hold myself to the same standard. My industrial background helped me see the possibility; other people’s expertise helped us build it. Experience should make us more precise about what we can judge—and more aware of what we have yet to understand.
I can leave a conversation accepting that I was wrong. What I no longer do is mistake someone else’s certainty for a limit on what I am capable of building.